Pianists’ Secrets: How the Best Performers Practice
· Updated
Why do some musicians play better than others? Psychologists have long studied how much and how professionals practice. Here is what that research found and what you can take from it for your own practice. Finger exercises are covered in Top 5 Exercises for Developing Finger Technique, and hand position in Piano Hand Position: The Foundation of Good Playing.
Where the 10,000 Hours Came From
In 1993, psychologist Anders Ericsson and his colleagues Ralf Krampe and Clemens Tesch-Römer published one of the most cited studies on expertise. They recruited three groups of ten violin students from the Music Academy of West Berlin: the best, the good and future music teachers. The students estimated how many hours a week they had practiced alone with the violin since they started. The authors concluded that the skill level of the groups fully matched how many hours of such practice each group had accumulated on average.
Journalist Malcolm Gladwell drew on this study to establish his “10,000-hour rule” in the book Outliers. Ericsson later wrote that the rule is wrong in several ways. 10,000 was the average number of hours of deliberate practice the best of these violinists had reached by age 20, and they were not yet masters at that point. The number of hours needed depends on the field. And Gladwell did not distinguish deliberate practice from other kinds of practice.
What Deliberate Practice Is
One of Ericsson’s core findings was that how expert someone becomes depends more on how they practice than on how many times they simply repeat a skill. An expert breaks the skill down into parts and works on improving each one, often with immediate feedback from a coach. Such practice has a clear goal, and the task comes from the teacher. How to apply this to a child’s home practice is covered in How Your Child Can Practice Piano at Home Between Lessons.
Pianists: Practice Maintains Skill
In 1996, Ralf Krampe and Anders Ericsson compared young and older pianists, both experts and accomplished amateurs. With age, everyone showed a marked decline in general processing speed as measured by standard tests. On music-related tasks, the amateurs also declined with age, but the experts did not: on average, the older experts were only slightly below the young ones. How well the older experts maintained their piano skills was predicted by the amount of deliberate practice in later adulthood.
Practice Matters, but It Is Not Everything
Later, the idea was tested on more data. In 2014, Brooke Macnamara, David Hambrick and Frederick Oswald combined studies of deliberate practice from all major domains where it had been studied into a meta-analysis. In music, it explained 21% of the differences in performance; in games, 26%; in sports, 18%. The authors concluded that deliberate practice is important, but not as important as had been argued.
In 2019, Macnamara and Megha Maitra repeated the 1993 violinist study, this time using a double-blind procedure. Overall, the link between practice and skill level was substantial, but much weaker than in the original study. The main finding, that accumulated hours of practice corresponded to each skill level, was not replicated.
What to Take from This
- Count how you practice, not the hours: each session should have a clear goal.
- Break a difficult passage into parts and improve each one.
- Feedback and assignments come from the teacher; without them, it is easy to keep repeating the same thing.
- Do not stop practicing once much of it works: among the older experts, those who practiced more in later adulthood maintained their skills better.
- Do not expect practice alone to decide everything: according to the meta-analysis, it explains only part of the differences between musicians.
How to Get Started
The easiest way is a trial lesson for $8: you will meet the teacher and see how lessons work. More about the course is on the Piano page.