Differences Between Soprano, Alto, and Tenor Recorders
· Updated
Recorders come in many sizes, and four of them see the most use today: soprano, alto, tenor and bass. Here is how the three most common ones, soprano, alto and tenor, differ in range, notation, fingering and where each is heard.
Sound and Lowest Note
- Soprano. The smallest of the three; its lowest note is C5. British usage calls it the descant.
- Alto. Larger, with a lowest note of F4, a fifth below the soprano. The British name is treble.
- Tenor. Larger again; its lowest note is C4, an octave under the soprano.
- Bass. Its lowest note is F3, an octave under the alto.
How the Music Is Written
Alto and tenor parts are written where they sound, while soprano and bass parts are written an octave lower than they sound. That is why soprano and tenor music looks the same on the page. Recorders are grouped as C or F instruments by their lowest note: with every hole closed, the soprano and tenor play C and the alto plays F. This leads to the main practical difference: the same written note takes a different fingering on a soprano than on an alto.
Size and Hands
The larger the recorder, the farther apart its holes. Keys appear most often on instruments bigger than the alto, and anything larger than a tenor needs at least one key, or the player could not reach all eight holes. Smaller recorders sometimes get keys too, for a more comfortable hand position. So the tenor asks for a wider finger stretch than the soprano or alto.
Where Each One Is Heard
- The alto was the main recorder of Baroque music; only a small share of the solo works of that era were written for other sizes.
- The soprano is a frequent first instrument: lessons usually begin on it.
- In ensembles, the sizes complement each other; a common lineup is a quartet of soprano, alto, tenor and bass. More in Recorder Ensembles: From Consorts to Bass Recorders.
Which One to Start On
You can begin on either the soprano or the alto; the choice depends on age, comfort and the lesson plan. The tenor usually comes later, once the hands cover the holes securely. For how to pick a specific model, see Choosing Your First Recorder: A Guide for Beginners.
Learning with Us
In our recorder course, students learn to hold the instrument properly and control their breathing, read notes and rhythms, and learn favorite tunes and pieces in a range of styles, with the option of performing at online concerts. Lessons are open to students from age 5. A trial lesson costs $8: it is individual and lasts 45 minutes. More about the course is on the Recorder page.